The three Fluoride
chemicals that could be added to Queensland water
supplies for fluoridation
are Hydrofluorosilicic Acid,
Sodium Silicofluoride or
Sodium Fluoride.
Hydrofluorosilicic Acid and
Sodium Silicofluoride are collectively known as the
Silicofluorides and are
the chemicals used most in other Australian states
fluoridation schemes.
The two Silicofluorides
chemicals used, are waste products of Phosphate
fertilizer manufacture.
They are industrial grade, not pharmaceutical grade
products and can contain
small residues of toxic heavy metals such as
cadmium, mercury or lead.
The two Silicofluoride compounds
used DO NOT EVEN OCCUR IN NATURE,
yet fluoridation promoters
call fluoride "NATURAL”. No toxicology studies have
ever been performed on the
Silicofluoride used in water fluoridation schemes.
The only toxicology studies
ever done, have been done on
Pharmaceutical grade Sodium
Fluoride as is used in toothpaste.
Currently less than 5% of
Queensland's population drinks fluoridated water.
Sodium Fluoride is a waste
product of Aluminium smelting and is the
fluoridation chemical used
in Queensland in Dalby, Mareeba, Moranbah and
Townsville/ Thuringowah.
Freedom of Information reveals
that water supply of Bamaga is fluoridated with
a Silicofluoride and that
Sodium Fluoride used in other Queensland areas is
imported from China.
It would appear that most
of the Queenslanders that are currently drinking
fluoridated water are drinking
water fluoridated with imported Chinese industry
waste products, probably
sourced as a waste product of the
Chinese Aluminium smelting
industry.
Water from rivers, creeks
or dams does contain small amounts of
natural fluoride.
Levels of fluoride in SE Qld surface waters are usually only
about 0.1 parts per million,
or nine times less the amount of the Fluoride that
Queensland Government plans
on adding to Brisbane's water supply.
Fluoride occurs naturally
in water when water flows though or over rocks and
abrades rocks that contain
Fluorspar, or Calcium Fluoride (Ca F2).
Calcium fluoride is very
insoluble. Water that contains natural Fluoride from
abraded Fluorspar containing
rocks also contains Calcium which can offer
some protection from Fluoride.
Fluoride binds with Calcium readily and
Calcium is given as a treatment
for Fluoride poisoning.
Calcium Fluoride (the natural
form of Fluoride) is not permitted to be added to
any Australian water supply.
Groundwater as in bore water
or well water can contain very high levels
of "natural" fluoride and
in parts of China, India and the Rift Valley,
natural Fluoride has led
to devastating health effects such as crippling
Skeletal Fluorosis for millions
of people. Arsenic, Lead and Mercury are
also "natural". Natural
does not necessarily mean good or desirable.
The Silicofluoride compounds
used for water fluoridation are very acidic and
addition to water often
entails addition of other chemicals such as soda ash to
neutralize the acidity to
prevent corrosion of water reticulation equipment.
Appendix one of the 1999
NHMRC Review of water fluoridation was a
questionaire for Councils
which fluoridate and included a request for any
evidence for Fluoride incompatibilities,
such as enhanced corrosion or
breakdown of gaskets or
seals, in the water distribution network.
The Queensland Government
has said they would pay the setting up costs of
fluoridation, but will not
be paying for any recurrent and on going costs.
Any Fluoride caused corrosion
problems in water treatment plants or water
reticulation systems would
be to the future cost of Councils and ratepayers.